Medicare plan reviews
What Should Medicare Agents Check Before Recommending a Plan Change During AEP?

Before recommending a Medicare plan change, review the client’s doctors, prescriptions, pharmacies, expected costs, and coverage restrictions. Compare the proposed plan with the current plan’s benefits for the upcoming year so the client understands what improves, what changes, and what they may give up.
Medicare Open Enrollment ends December 7. Changes made during this period generally take effect January 1, making November a useful time to resolve questions before the deadline.
Where should a Medicare review begin?
Start with the client’s needs and the current plan’s upcoming changes.
Ask what has changed since the last review:
- New doctors, specialists, or treatment locations.
- Added medications or different dosages.
- Planned procedures or ongoing treatment.
- Changes in budget, travel, or living arrangements.
Review the Annual Notice of Change and relevant Evidence of Coverage. CMS encourages beneficiaries to review those materials during Open Enrollment.
A comparison against last year’s benefits alone can miss changes already scheduled for the current plan.
How should agents check doctors and prescriptions?
Verify the exact plan, provider location, medication, and pharmacy involved.
A client saying, “My doctor takes that insurance company,” does not establish participation in the specific plan you are discussing. Check current plan information and resolve conflicting answers with the carrier and provider.
For prescriptions, review:
- Drug name, strength, quantity, and frequency.
- Formulary coverage and cost tier.
- Pharmacy participation and estimated costs.
- Prior authorization, step therapy, or quantity limits.
Official Medicare counseling guidance recommends comparing costs, networks, and prescription benefits and confirming important details directly with the plan.
How do you explain a plan’s tradeoffs?
Show the client the differences that matter to their situation.
For example, Robert, a fictional Medicare beneficiary, likes a proposed plan’s additional benefits. During the review, his agent discovers that participation by his longtime specialist is uncertain.
The next step is to resolve that question before treating the plan as a suitable replacement. An attractive extra benefit does not answer the client’s concerns about continuing treatment.
A useful explanation is:
“This plan improves these benefits, but these costs and coverage details also change. Let’s review how those differences affect the care you actually use.”
What should agents document before enrollment?
Record the basis for the recommendation and any unresolved issue.
A practical review record includes:
- The client’s stated priorities.
- The plans and plan year compared.
- Provider and prescription checks, including their dates.
- Material costs, restrictions, and tradeoffs discussed.
- The client’s decision and any remaining follow-up.
Follow current carrier and CMS requirements for the sales appointment and enrollment process.
What questions should the review answer?
Does every client need to switch plans during AEP?
No. A review may support keeping the existing plan.
Is a lower premium enough to recommend a change?
No. Consider the client’s likely total costs and access to care.
What if provider information conflicts?
Resolve the discrepancy and explain any remaining uncertainty before the client decides.
A thorough review should leave the client understanding the decision—not simply remembering the plan’s most attractive benefit.
Want help improving your Medicare review process? Email [email protected], call or text 210-972-9558, or visit IAT.Agency.